The Stanley Sadie Handel Recording Prize 2005
Haendel: Opera Seria
- Berenice: 'Scoglio d’immota fronte' (from Scipione; HWV 20)
- Angelica: 'Erbette liete verdi piante' (from Orlando; HWV 31)
- Cleopatra: 'Che sento oh dio' (from Giulio Cesare in
Egitto; HWV 17)
- Cleopatra: 'Se pietà' (from Giulio Cesare in Egitto; HWV 17)
- Partenope: 'L'amor ed il destin...' (from Partenope; HWV 27)
- Melissa: 'Ah spietato' (from Amadigi di Gaula; HWV 11)
- Rossane: 'Brilla nell'alma un non inteso ancor' (from Alessandro; HWV 21)
- Rodelinda: 'Ombre piante' (from Rodelinda; HWV 19)
- Clotilde: 'Combattuta da due venti' (from Faramondo; HWV 39)
- Deidamia: 'M’ai resa infelice' (from Deidamia; HWV 42)
- Alceste: 'Son qual stanco pellegrino' (from Arianna in
Creta; HWV 32)
Sandrine Piau, soprano
Les Talens Lyriques (on period instruments)
(Read the Review.)
This year we are delighted to congratulate Sandrine Piau,
Christophe Rousset, Les Talens Lyriques and Naïve upon the award of first
prize for their recording of Italian opera arias from Handel’s London
operas. We congratulate them for producing such a distinguished and
exemplary recording. The panel’s overwhelming verdict in favour of Opera
Seria confirms that is a superb recital on every count: stimulating,
well-thought out and far from hackneyed repertoire, excellent orchestral
playing, and glorious faultless singing imbued with both taste and feeling.
It is unusual for a recital disc to provide such a satisfying and
stimulating experience, yet Rousset and Piau have devised a programme that
is a sublime exploration of Handel’s operatic genius.
We also wish to commend this year's runner-up: a charming performance of
Handel's Ode to St Cecilia by Robert King and The King’s
Consort (Hyperion). (Read the review.) The long overdue recording of
Handel’s late opera Imeneo (CPO) was also highly commended by
the panel. (Read the review.)
What is The International Handel Recording Prize?
It is an annual award given to one distinctive new
recording of Handel's music. Hitherto known as The International Handel
Recording Prize, it is chosen by a specially invited panel of respected
scholars and journalists who each possess a special and informed interest in
Handel’s music. In some respects it was influenced by the now defunct
American Handel Society Recording Prize (1991-1998), but in 2002 an
international panel of judges inaugurated a broader forum to nurture
recognition to a new recording of Handel’s music of noteworthy quality. This
year’s winner was chosen by judges from Australia, France, Germany, Italy,
Russia, England and the U.S.A.
The winner is carefully selected from a comprehensive
list of all new recordings of Handel’s music released during the previous
calendar year. The winner must satisfy tough criteria: it needs to combine
fine interpretive quality with a penetrating or valuable insight into
Handel’s genius. Thus this Prize is an indication of a disc’s quality and
its contribution to Handelian knowledge. The panel of judges constitutes
respected Handel musicologists and journalists who can discern those
recordings which make valuable contributions to the discography.
Furthermore, this prize is purely idealistic: it is an indication of a
genuinely special recording, and is designed to encourage unique and
supportive recognition from a cross-section of those who care most about the
One of the prize’s founder panel members was the scholar,
author and critic Stanley Sadie. Due to illness Stanley was unable to vote
this year, and sadly he passed away in March 2005. We shall miss his brilliantly
perceptive reviews of Handel recordings in The Gramophone that were
notable for their enthusiasm, erudition and joy for the music. The Panel
wishes to recognize Stanley Sadie’s devotion to Handel recordings during his
distinguished career, and is honoured to rename the prize in his honour. The
Prize has unparalleled integrity and standards, which is a fitting testament
to the perceptive and accessible critical style of Stanley Sadie, whose love
for Handel‘s music was influential upon thousands of music lovers. Unlike
such prizes awarded solely by scholars, or only by critics, our panel
comfortably blends the commonly opposed perspectives of historical
musicology and constructive criticism. We hope that this is warmly accepted
as an appropriate legacy of Stanley Sadie’s unusual ease at mingling
enjoyable journalism and superb scholarship together.
This Year's Panel of Judges:
Sandra Bowdler (Andante.com - Perth, Australia)
Hugh Canning (The Sunday
Times and International Record Review - London)
(Handel scholar - Moscow)
Philippe Gelinaud (Handel
scholar, Opéra International - Paris)
Anthony Hicks (Handel scholar, Early Music Review, The Handel Institute - London)
Brad Leissa (GFHandel.org, American Handel Society - Washington D.C.)
Michael Pacholke (musicologist, Hallische Händel-Ausgabe - Halle)
Benedikt Poensgen (Göttingen Händel-Festpiele - Göttingen)
David Vickers (The Gramophone, GFHandel.org - Huddersfield)
Carlo Vitali (musicologist,
freelance author - Bologna)
The Candidate List
(in no particular order)
Live recording 1968: English Bach Festival Orchestra; Anthony Lewis; Ponto.
Collegium Cartusianum; K ölner Kammerchor; Peter
Live recording 1950; Coro e Orchestra del Teatro San Carlo Napoli, Herbert
Capella Augustina; Andreas Spering; CPO.
Il Complesso Barocco; Alan Curtis. DHM.
Kammerorchester Basel, Paul Goodwin. Oehms.
Ode to St. Cecilia; Cecilia, volgi
The King’s Consort; Robert King. Hyperion.
Ode to St. Cecilia
Concerto Polacco; Wolfgang Helbich. Naxos.
Stuttgart Chamber Orchestra, George Petrou, MD&G.
The Gabrieli Consort; Paul McCreesh. DG Archiv.
Capella Augustina; Andreas Spering; Harmonia Mundi.
Opera Fuoco; David Stern. Arion.
Les Arts Florissants; William Christie. Virgin Veritas.
[no eligible recordings this year]
Vocal music and recitals:
Amor e Gelosia (Opera Duets)
Il Complesso Barocco; Alan Curtis. Virgin Veritas.
Renee Fleming (soprano); Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment; Harry Bicket.
Lorraine Hunt-Lieberson (mezzo-soprano); Orchestra of the Age of
Enlightenment; Harry Bicket. Avie.
Heroes and Heroines: Handel Arias
Sarah Connolly (mezzo-soprano); Symphony of Harmony and Invention; Harry
Arcadia; Jacqueline Ogeil. Tall Poppies.
Nel dolce dell'Oblio (Italian cantatas and German arias)
Amanda Pabyan (soprano); Callisto.
Sandrine Piau (soprano); Les Talens Lyriques; Christophe Rousset. Naive.
Sacred & Profane
Robert Expert (countertenor); Amarillis. Ambroisie.
Orchestral / Instrumental:
Concerti grossi Op.3
Ensemble La Passione; Thomas Fey (director); Accent.
Vahan Mardirossian (piano); Intrada.
Christian Schmitt (organ); Stuttgart Chamber Orchestra; Nicol Matt.
Pamela Thorby (recorder); Richard Egarr (harpsichord / organ); Linn.
Sonatas for the Recorder
Dorothee Oberlinger (recorder); Ensemble
1700. Marc Aurel Edition.
Suites de Pieces pour le Clavecin (2 volumes)
Ottavio Dantone (harpsichord); Arts.
London Mozart Players; Jane Glover (conductor); Resonance.
Pasticcio oratorio arranged by J.C. Smith Jnr. and Thomas Morell; Joachim
Carlos Martini (director); Naxos.
Endnote: A live recording of Rinaldo (conducted by Nicholas McGegan and featuring Diana Moore, Dominique Labelle,
Cyndia Sieden, Andrew Foster-Williams, and Concerto Köln) was not eligible for
consideration because it is only available to members of the Göttinger Händel
Gesellschaft (Göttingen Handel Society).
The International Handel Recording Prize was inspired by The American
Handel Society's Recording Prize. The AHS Recording Prize was awarded on an
annual basis between 1991-1998.
explicitly specified otherwise,
this page and all other pages at this site are Copyright © 2015 by David
Vickers and Matthew Gardner
August 30, 2020
· Site design: Duncan Fielden, Matthew Gardner and David Vickers