The Handel Institute

"Crude Furie degli orridi abissi - Evil Arias by G. F. Händel"
 

Callisto Records CLS 0102
1 CD
+ 1 PC & Mac compatible CD-ROM with music (16 mp3 files), English and Italian booklet with many photos (in html and jpg format) and scores (in pdf format)
Recorded in 2001.
Released in 2001.

  •  Ouverture from Admeto (HWV 22)
  •  Crude furie degli orridi abissi, sung by Serse from Serse (HWV 40)
  •  Agitato il cor mi sento, sung by Dardano from Amadigi (HWV 11)
  •  Pena tiranna, sung by Dardano from Amadigi (HWV 11)
  •  Voglio che sia l’indegno, sung by Faramondo from Faramondo (HWV 39)
  •  Nella terra, in ciel, nell’onda, sung by Gernando from Faramondo (HWV 39)
  •  Concerto grosso Op. 3 No. 3 (HWV 314)
  •  Vano amore, sung by Alessandro from Alessandro (HWV 21)
  •  Su! All’armi, sung by Evaneo from Rodrigo (HWV 5)
  •  Furibondo spira il vento, sung by Arsace from Partenope (HWV 27)
  •  Voglio stragi e voglio morte, sung by Egeo from Teseo (HWV 9)
  •  Son stanco… / Deggio morire, sung by Siroe from Siroe (HWV 24)
  •  A dispetto d’un volto ingrato, sung by Tamerlano from Tamerlano (HWV 18)
 Bonus CD (in mp3 format):
  • Tu preparati a morire, sung by Ariodante from Ariodante (HWV 33)
  • Trio sonata Op. 2 No. 1 (HWV 386b)
 Angelo Manzotti (sopranist)
 Ensemble Rocinante (on period instruments)
 Director: Tito Ceccherini

To produce a CD of arias sung by the “baddies” from Handel operas is a good idea. All the more since many of these arias are beautiful and rarely recorded. Although several of the choices are questionable: you can hardly find a character as far from being a villain than Faramondo, and are Serse, Arsace or Siroe really evil characters? At least this rather commercial approach is a good occasion to listen to Faramondo’s great aria “Voglio che sia l’indegno” or the dramatic “Deggio morire” from Siroe. The programme is really interesting and the presence of a CD-ROM containing the scores makes such a product being particularly attractive. However, what about the interpretation?

Once more, the sopranist Angelo Manzotti offers us an extraordinary recording. He sings very high and quite low notes, but unfortunately, his singing is a demonstration of forcing. Consequently all those high notes and many others are out of tune and the vowels are distorted (on a long run you can ear three or four different sounds on a single vowel!). This frequently renders the text incomprehensible (“Peno tiranno” is not a rediscovered version of “Pena tiranna”!). Is it necessary to add that the passagio is weak and the “dramatic intensity” is too often obtained by an artificial vibrato and quavering recitatives? There are some moments in the lower lying arias which make one think Manzotti could have been a reasonable countertenor and some of his variations are really interesting, but even in alto arias he adds some terribly sung cadenze. His singing is never moving and not even impressive, just caricatured and unbearable. Good intentions do not make good singing.

A very interesting programme, an excellent editorial policy, and a really good Finnish orchestra. Yet even if Manzotti certainly has some talent, this is unacceptable singing. People interested in sopranists should instead listen to the young French Philippe Jaroussky, definitely one of the best yet heard both in concert and on recordings.

© Philippe Gelinaud - February 2002


Return to the G. F. Handel Home Page


Unless explicitly specified otherwise, this page and all other pages at this site are Copyright © 2015 by David Vickers and Matthew Gardner

GFHandel.org credits

Last updated: June 8, 2016  · Site design: Duncan Fielden, Matthew Gardner and David Vickers