Newsgroup: Rec.Music.Early
Post: Re: Brandenburg Recommendations
From: cornflwr@cornflwr.demon.co.uk (Michele Kohler)
Date: August 17, 1995

It was, it was - transfered to cd - RCA RD 70794 (2) and also RCA GD 87724.

Now, wonderful as that recording is/was the new recording by La Petite Bande DHM 05472 77308 2 is to my taste even better. Some of you may not like the fact that there is a horn instead of a trumpet in No. 2 but that was Sigiswald Kuijken's decision and he gives his reasons in the notes. In fact all of the quick movements are quicker than the old Leonhardt - for it was Leonhardt who was the moving force behind the earlier one - recording and all of the slower movements are slower. It is just the way that *I* always wanted it to sound. There is nothing harsh about the sound at all. Critics have been mixed - some angry about the horn instead of trumpet calling the director all sorts of names in print! Someone objected to the practice of a violinist playing the viola in no. 6 - a mean criticism. And like the earlier Leonhardt recording there are friends playing along together. There are no gimmicks in this recording. Nothing is vulgar. It is what it is.


Forward

Back

Return to the PIPE List.